The below table illustrates my experience with all of the online vendors from whom I have purchased seed through the years. This is not a definitive comparison as results will vary per individual grower.

Scale: Excellent, Good, Fair, Poor

Company Selection True to Variety Germination Notes
Atlantic Pepper Seeds Excellent tbd tbd
Baker Creek Heirloom Good Good Excellent
Bohica Pepper Hut Excellent tbd tbd
Burpee Fair Good Excellent
Hippy Seed Co Excellent Excellent Excellent
Kearley Seeds & Pepper Co Good Good Fair Closed
Pepper Donkey Excellent Fair Good Hobbyist
Puckerbutt Pepper Co Excellent Excellent Excellent
Refining Fire Chiles Excellent Good Good
Tyler Farms Excellent Excellent Excellent
White Hot Peppers Excellent tbd Excellent Hobbyist